Fastest-Appreciating ZIP Codes in Rutland, VT (2026)

Ranked by 5-year compound annual growth in home values. Fast growth and strong cash flow rarely appear in the same ZIP — this is the other side of that trade.

# ZIP City Home value Rent Cap rate 5-yr growth
1 05751 Killington, VT $502,438 $1,602 2.49% 7.0%
2 05765 Proctor, VT $270,699 $1,314 3.79% 6.5%
3 05701 Rutland, VT $295,790 $1,401 3.70% 6.3%
4 05736 Rutland, VT $306,602 $1,215 3.09% 6.3%
5 05764 Poultney, VT $290,130 $1,062 2.86% 6.2%
6 05763 Pittsford, VT $321,002 $1,269 3.08% 6.0%
7 05774 Wells, VT $359,303 $1,368 2.97% 5.9%
8 05777 West Rutland, VT $271,700 $1,314 3.77% 5.5%
9 05735 Castleton, VT $317,949 $1,566 3.84% 5.4%
10 05773 Wallingford, VT $322,159 $1,233 2.99% 5.3%
11 05737 Chittenden, VT $384,104 $1,197 2.43% 5.2%
12 05743 Fair Haven, VT $272,166 $1,206 3.46% 5.2%
13 05758 Mt Holly, VT $406,157 $1,314 2.52% 4.9%
14 05732 Castleton, VT $369,306 $1,044 2.20% 4.8%
15 05733 Brandon, VT $321,359 $1,296 3.15% 4.5%
16 05744 Pittsford, VT $275,042 $1,359 3.85% 4.4%
17 05759 Clarendon, VT $330,765 $1,242 2.93% 4.2%
18 05757 Middletown Springs, VT $353,551 $1,431 3.16% 3.6%
19 05742 Wallingford, VT $366,555 $1,098 2.34% 3.5%
20 05739 Danby, VT $364,576 $1,260 2.70% 2.8%
21 05775 Pawlet, VT $289,475 $1,242 3.35% 2.6%
22 05738 Shrewsbury, VT $357,666 $1,548 3.38% 2.1%
23 05761 Pawlet, VT $411,000 $1,575 2.99% -0.2%

Ranked from Repit’s own ZIP-level data — Zillow home values and rents, HUD fair-market rents where Zillow has no coverage, and U.S. Census vacancy. Cap rate is gross: annual rent over purchase price, before financing and expenses. Every ZIP above links to its full free page. How we calculate this →

Same metro, different strategy

Cash Flow in Rutland, VT  ·  Affordable in Rutland, VT

Or see the full Rutland, VT metro profile.