Poughkeepsie-Newburgh-Middletown, NY Metro Area - Investment Guide

Metro Area • 65 Cities • 67 ZIP Codes

Avg Home Value $514,232
Avg Monthly Rent $2,074
Avg Cap Rate 3.27%
Avg Investability 3.0 ★
Cities 65
ZIP Codes 67

This metro is one of hundreds you can screen side by side — filter by the numbers that matter and get alerts when they move. See plans →

🏦 30-yr Fixed Rate: 6.76% as of Sep 10 Source: Freddie Mac PMMS

Best ZIP codes in Poughkeepsie-Newburgh-Middletown, NY

Every ZIP in the metro, ranked four ways. Free.

Cash Flow → Appreciation → Affordable →

Cities in Poughkeepsie-Newburgh-Middletown, NY

Amenia New York 1 ZIPs Beacon New York 1 ZIPs Blooming Grove New York 1 ZIPs Bloomingburg New York 1 ZIPs Campbell Hall New York 1 ZIPs Central Valley New York 1 ZIPs Chester New York 1 ZIPs Circleville New York 1 ZIPs Clinton Corners New York 1 ZIPs Cornwall New York 1 ZIPs Cornwall on Hudson New York 1 ZIPs Cuddebackville New York 1 ZIPs Dover Plains New York 1 ZIPs Fishkill New York 1 ZIPs Florida New York 1 ZIPs Fort Montgomery New York 1 ZIPs Goshen New York 1 ZIPs Greenwood Lake New York 1 ZIPs Harriman New York 1 ZIPs Highland Falls New York 1 ZIPs Highland Mills New York 1 ZIPs Holmes New York 1 ZIPs Hopewell Junction New York 1 ZIPs Huguenot New York 1 ZIPs Hyde Park New York 1 ZIPs Lagrangeville New York 1 ZIPs Maybrook New York 1 ZIPs Middletown New York 2 ZIPs Millbrook New York 1 ZIPs Millerton New York 1 ZIPs Monroe New York 1 ZIPs Montgomery New York 1 ZIPs New Hampton New York 1 ZIPs New Windsor New York 1 ZIPs Newburgh New York 1 ZIPs Otisville New York 1 ZIPs Pawling New York 1 ZIPs Pine Island New York 1 ZIPs Pine Plains New York 1 ZIPs Pleasant Valley New York 1 ZIPs Port Jervis New York 1 ZIPs Poughkeepsie New York 3 ZIPs Poughquag New York 1 ZIPs Red Hook New York 1 ZIPs Rhinebeck New York 1 ZIPs Rhinecliff New York 1 ZIPs Rock Tavern New York 1 ZIPs Salisbury Mills New York 1 ZIPs Salt Point New York 1 ZIPs Slate Hill New York 1 ZIPs Sparrow Bush New York 1 ZIPs Staatsburg New York 1 ZIPs Stanfordville New York 1 ZIPs Stormville New York 1 ZIPs Tuxedo Park New York 1 ZIPs Unionville New York 1 ZIPs Verbank New York 1 ZIPs Walden New York 1 ZIPs Wappingers Falls New York 1 ZIPs Warwick New York 1 ZIPs Washingtonville New York 1 ZIPs Wassaic New York 1 ZIPs Westtown New York 1 ZIPs Wingdale New York 1 ZIPs Wurtsboro New York 2 ZIPs

Top ZIP Codes by Investability

ZIP Code City State Home Value Rent Cap Rate Rating
10928 Highland Falls NY $423,007 $3,533 6.52% 4.0 ★
10928 Highland Falls NY $411,871 $3,533 6.69% 4.0 ★
12729 Cuddebackville NY $299,603 $1,602 4.17% 4.0 ★
10928 Highland Falls NY $427,430 $3,533 6.45% 4.0 ★
12729 Cuddebackville NY $299,603 $1,602 4.17% 4.0 ★
10921 Florida NY $470,888 $2,133 3.53% 3.0 ★
10987 Tuxedo Park NY $1,246,144 $2,259 1.41% 3.0 ★
12538 Hyde Park NY $398,344 $1,548 3.03% 3.0 ★
12572 Rhinebeck NY $693,268 $2,933 3.30% 3.0 ★
12603 Poughkeepsie NY $436,361 $2,208 3.95% 3.0 ★
10928 Highland Falls NY $417,513 $1,980 3.70% 3.0 ★
10998 Westtown NY $556,104 $1,872 2.63% 3.0 ★
12546 Millerton NY $468,812 $1,548 2.58% 3.0 ★
12580 Staatsburg NY $469,050 $1,548 2.57% 3.0 ★
12780 Sparrow Bush NY $341,395 $1,548 3.54% 3.0 ★
10916 Campbell Hall NY $588,110 $1,800 2.39% 3.0 ★
10950 Monroe NY $530,676 $3,054 4.49% 3.0 ★
12520 Cornwall on Hudson NY $542,837 $1,900 2.73% 3.0 ★
12567 Pine Plains NY $435,368 $1,719 3.08% 3.0 ★
12586 Walden NY $426,534 $2,150 3.93% 3.0 ★
10917 Central Valley NY $551,917 $2,187 3.09% 3.0 ★
10958 New Hampton NY $491,048 $2,376 3.77% 3.0 ★
12522 Dover Plains NY $411,333 $1,548 2.94% 3.0 ★
12569 Pleasant Valley NY $472,214 $2,097 3.46% 3.0 ★
12590 Wappingers Falls NY $508,346 $2,460 3.78% 3.0 ★
10922 Fort Montgomery NY $463,258 $1,701 2.86% 3.0 ★
10988 Unionville NY $335,336 $1,674 3.89% 3.0 ★
12540 Lagrangeville NY $555,133 $2,250 3.16% 3.0 ★
12574 Rhinecliff NY $717,859 $1,791 1.95% 3.0 ★
12721 Bloomingburg NY $426,924 $1,548 2.83% 3.0 ★
10930 Highland Mills NY $531,181 $2,196 3.22% 3.0 ★
12501 Amenia NY $525,503 $1,548 2.30% 3.0 ★
12549 Montgomery NY $500,615 $1,836 2.86% 3.0 ★
12581 Stanfordville NY $538,154 $1,548 2.24% 3.0 ★
12785 Wurtsboro NY $334,226 $1,548 3.61% 3.0 ★
10940 Middletown NY $389,545 $2,398 4.80% 3.0 ★
12508 Beacon NY $565,231 $2,940 4.06% 3.0 ★
12550 Newburgh NY $400,528 $1,983 3.86% 3.0 ★
12582 Stormville NY $543,657 $2,259 3.24% 3.0 ★
10918 Chester NY $518,361 $2,931 4.41% 3.0 ★
10963 Otisville NY $441,065 $1,548 2.74% 3.0 ★
12524 Fishkill NY $471,342 $1,975 3.27% 3.0 ★
12570 Poughquag NY $546,193 $1,989 2.84% 3.0 ★
12592 Wassaic NY $439,025 $1,548 2.75% 3.0 ★
10924 Goshen NY $569,270 $2,830 3.88% 3.0 ★
10990 Warwick NY $554,222 $2,725 3.84% 3.0 ★
12543 Maybrook NY $317,736 $1,773 4.35% 3.0 ★
12575 Rock Tavern NY $598,905 $1,764 2.30% 3.0 ★
12729 Cuddebackville NY $291,121 $1,602 4.29% 3.0 ★
10992 Washingtonville NY $509,183 $1,746 2.67% 3.0 ★

Showing top 50 of 67 ZIP codes. View all →

A great house in the wrong ZIP is still a bad deal — screen every market by cash flow & cap rate.
Open the Market Finder →
Free to search · investor plans from $19/mo

About Poughkeepsie-Newburgh-Middletown, NY Real Estate Market

The Poughkeepsie-Newburgh-Middletown, NY metropolitan statistical area (MSA) encompasses 65 cities and 67 ZIP codes. The average home value across the metro is $514,232, with an average monthly rent of $2,074. Explore individual cities and ZIP codes to find investment opportunities that match your criteria.