Most Affordable ZIP Codes in York-Hanover, PA (2026)

The lowest entry prices that still hold a decent investability rating — cheap is only useful if the market underneath it is sound.

# ZIP City Home value Rent Cap rate 5-yr growth
1 17401 York, PA $148,849 $1,202 6.30% 11.6%
2 17318 York, PA $227,184 $1,350 4.64% 8.3%
3 17403 York, PA $254,916 $1,362 4.17% 7.0%
4 17404 York, PA $261,229 $1,315 3.93% 7.1%
5 17368 Wrightsville, PA $282,175 $2,800 7.74% 7.2%
6 17313 Dallastown, PA $282,280 $976 2.70% 6.5%
7 17345 Manchester, PA $284,220 $1,197 3.28% 6.3%
8 17315 Dover, PA $295,543 $1,737 4.58% 6.1%
9 17331 Hanover, PA $298,460 $1,384 3.62% 6.0%
10 17356 Red Lion, PA $298,646 $1,781 4.65% 6.1%
11 17406 York, PA $299,496 $1,669 4.35% 6.2%
12 17408 York, PA $300,393 $1,662 4.32% 6.1%
13 17366 Windsor, PA $313,643 $1,278 3.18% 6.5%
14 17319 Etters, PA $321,625 $1,650 4.00% 6.3%
15 17314 Delta, PA $322,647 $1,125 2.72% 6.0%
16 17370 York Haven, PA $323,785 $1,188 2.86% 6.3%
17 17347 Mount Wolf, PA $329,050 $1,708 4.05% 6.6%
18 17402 York, PA $333,228 $1,690 3.96% 5.9%
19 17407 Jacobus, PA $336,009 $1,791 4.16% 6.1%
20 17362 Spring Grove, PA $336,739 $1,223 2.83% 6.4%
21 17364 Thomasville, PA $341,668 $1,242 2.84% 5.8%
22 17302 Airville, PA $345,002 $1,161 2.62% 5.6%
23 17322 Felton, PA $354,048 $1,332 2.93% 6.5%
24 17309 Brogue, PA $355,152 $1,278 2.81% 6.4%
25 17361 Shrewsbury, PA $360,365 $1,197 2.59% 4.6%

Ranked from Repit’s own ZIP-level data — Zillow home values and rents, HUD fair-market rents where Zillow has no coverage, and U.S. Census vacancy. Cap rate is gross: annual rent over purchase price, before financing and expenses. Every ZIP above links to its full free page. How we calculate this →

Same metro, different strategy

Cash Flow in York-Hanover, PA  ·  Appreciation in York-Hanover, PA

Or see the full York-Hanover, PA metro profile.