Jamestown-Dunkirk-Fredonia, NY Metro Area - Investment Guide

Metro Area • 30 Cities • 30 ZIP Codes

Avg Home Value $205,285
Avg Monthly Rent $940
Avg Cap Rate 4.22%
Avg Investability 3.1 ★
Cities 30
ZIP Codes 30

This metro is one of hundreds you can screen side by side — filter by the numbers that matter and get alerts when they move. See plans →

🏦 30-yr Fixed Rate: 6.76% as of Sep 10 Source: Freddie Mac PMMS

Best ZIP codes in Jamestown-Dunkirk-Fredonia, NY

Every ZIP in the metro, ranked four ways. Free.

Cash Flow → Appreciation → Affordable →

Cities in Jamestown-Dunkirk-Fredonia, NY

Top ZIP Codes by Investability

ZIP Code City State Home Value Rent Cap Rate Rating
14720 Celoron NY $93,200 $972 8.13% 5.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $96,814 $972 7.83% 5.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $96,762 $972 7.84% 5.0 ★
14740 Gerry NY $169,732 $1,314 6.04% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $68,640 $945 10.74% 4.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $100,588 $972 7.54% 4.0 ★
14701 Jamestown NY $120,626 $957 6.19% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $60,331 $945 12.22% 4.0 ★
14740 Gerry NY $169,732 $1,314 6.04% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $64,791 $945 11.38% 4.0 ★
14701 Jamestown NY $118,195 $920 6.07% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $60,331 $945 12.22% 4.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $98,256 $972 7.72% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $66,310 $945 11.12% 4.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $98,932 $972 7.66% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $67,285 $945 10.95% 4.0 ★
14720 Celoron NY $100,588 $972 7.54% 4.0 ★
14752 Lily Dale NY $58,550 $945 12.59% 4.0 ★
14723 Cherry Creek NY $160,456 $909 4.42% 4.0 ★
14063 Fredonia NY $209,280 $954 3.56% 3.0 ★
14736 Findley Lake NY $325,634 $927 2.22% 3.0 ★
14787 Westfield NY $188,265 $873 3.62% 3.0 ★
14712 Bemus Point NY $331,027 $873 2.06% 3.0 ★
14750 Lakewood NY $241,140 $1,233 3.99% 3.0 ★
14722 Chautauqua NY $598,028 $873 1.14% 3.0 ★
14775 Ripley NY $138,334 $873 4.92% 3.0 ★
14723 Cherry Creek NY $168,754 $909 4.20% 3.0 ★
14781 Sherman NY $161,918 $999 4.81% 3.0 ★
14136 Silver Creek NY $187,154 $990 4.13% 3.0 ★
14716 Brocton NY $150,165 $873 4.53% 3.0 ★
14724 Clymer NY $234,778 $873 2.90% 3.0 ★
14782 Sinclairville NY $151,801 $1,044 5.36% 3.0 ★
14138 South Dayton NY $144,174 $918 4.97% 3.0 ★
14742 Greenhurst NY $211,556 $873 3.22% 3.0 ★
14718 Cassadaga NY $175,543 $945 4.20% 3.0 ★
14757 Mayville NY $263,977 $873 2.58% 3.0 ★
14767 Panama NY $195,388 $873 3.49% 3.0 ★
14048 Dunkirk NY $136,900 $936 5.33% 3.0 ★
14728 Dewittville NY $270,091 $900 2.60% 3.0 ★
14784 Stockton NY $125,909 $891 5.52% 3.0 ★
14747 Kennedy NY $154,055 $873 4.42% 3.0 ★
14710 Ashville NY $237,718 $873 2.86% 3.0 ★
14750 Lakewood NY $217,255 $1,233 4.43% 3.0 ★
14722 Chautauqua NY $587,511 $873 1.16% 3.0 ★
14769 Portland NY $181,094 $873 3.76% 3.0 ★
14062 Forestville NY $205,322 $1,035 3.93% 3.0 ★
14733 Falconer NY $135,821 $873 5.01% 3.0 ★
14787 Westfield NY $168,265 $873 4.05% 3.0 ★
14063 Fredonia NY $218,893 $954 3.40% 3.0 ★
14736 Findley Lake NY $324,170 $927 2.23% 3.0 ★
A great house in the wrong ZIP is still a bad deal — screen every market by cash flow & cap rate.
Open the Market Finder →
Free to search · investor plans from $19/mo

About Jamestown-Dunkirk-Fredonia, NY Real Estate Market

The Jamestown-Dunkirk-Fredonia, NY metropolitan statistical area (MSA) encompasses 30 cities and 30 ZIP codes. The average home value across the metro is $205,285, with an average monthly rent of $940. Explore individual cities and ZIP codes to find investment opportunities that match your criteria.