Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY Metro Area - Investment Guide

Metro Area • 51 Cities • 79 ZIP Codes

Avg Home Value $303,356
Avg Monthly Rent $1,339
Avg Cap Rate 3.81%
Avg Investability 3.1 ★
Cities 51
ZIP Codes 79

This metro is one of hundreds you can screen side by side — filter by the numbers that matter and get alerts when they move. See plans →

🏦 30-yr Fixed Rate: 6.76% as of Sep 10 Source: Freddie Mac PMMS

Best ZIP codes in Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY

Every ZIP in the metro, ranked four ways. Free.

Cash Flow → Appreciation → Affordable →

Cities in Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY

Top ZIP Codes by Investability

ZIP Code City State Home Value Rent Cap Rate Rating
14204 Buffalo NY $184,416 $1,937 8.19% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $109,611 $1,217 8.66% 5.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $108,824 $1,208 8.66% 5.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $113,095 $1,207 8.32% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $109,611 $1,217 8.66% 5.0 ★
14301 Niagara Falls NY $107,758 $1,105 8.00% 5.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $101,819 $1,030 7.89% 5.0 ★
14204 Buffalo NY $184,707 $2,048 8.65% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $118,227 $1,200 7.92% 5.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $113,203 $1,207 8.31% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $119,631 $1,233 8.04% 5.0 ★
14208 Buffalo NY $132,624 $1,388 8.16% 5.0 ★
14204 Buffalo NY $189,666 $2,021 8.31% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $109,535 $1,217 8.66% 5.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $109,482 $1,117 7.96% 5.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $122,179 $1,236 7.89% 5.0 ★
14210 Buffalo NY $174,998 $1,254 5.59% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $151,346 $1,200 6.18% 4.0 ★
14215 Buffalo NY $144,013 $1,285 6.96% 4.0 ★
14211 Buffalo NY $120,058 $1,158 7.53% 4.0 ★
14301 Niagara Falls NY $118,349 $1,194 7.87% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $158,814 $1,250 6.14% 4.0 ★
14204 Buffalo NY $185,005 $1,853 7.81% 4.0 ★
14305 Niagara Falls NY $156,172 $1,400 6.99% 4.0 ★
14215 Buffalo NY $150,973 $1,280 6.61% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $151,346 $1,200 6.18% 4.0 ★
14215 Buffalo NY $144,013 $1,285 6.96% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $155,087 $1,200 6.04% 4.0 ★
14305 Niagara Falls NY $154,956 $1,400 7.05% 4.0 ★
14301 Niagara Falls NY $112,224 $1,114 7.74% 4.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $107,850 $1,030 7.45% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $158,474 $1,250 6.15% 4.0 ★
14305 Niagara Falls NY $146,669 $1,107 5.89% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $146,519 $1,200 6.39% 4.0 ★
14204 Buffalo NY $180,713 $1,770 7.64% 4.0 ★
14301 Niagara Falls NY $112,224 $1,114 7.74% 4.0 ★
14206 Buffalo NY $172,351 $1,062 4.81% 4.0 ★
14303 Niagara Falls NY $107,850 $1,030 7.45% 4.0 ★
14207 Buffalo NY $155,726 $1,248 6.25% 4.0 ★
14208 Buffalo NY $139,348 $1,388 7.77% 4.0 ★
14212 Buffalo NY $161,487 $1,250 6.04% 4.0 ★
14025 Boston NY $366,400 $1,062 2.26% 3.0 ★
14057 Eden NY $329,991 $1,161 2.74% 3.0 ★
14102 Marilla NY $376,209 $1,197 2.48% 3.0 ★
14172 Wilson NY $261,441 $1,161 3.46% 3.0 ★
14214 Buffalo NY $297,350 $1,578 4.14% 3.0 ★
14228 Buffalo NY $351,716 $1,872 4.15% 3.0 ★
14032 Clarence Center NY $583,934 $1,809 2.42% 3.0 ★
14072 Grand Island NY $376,579 $1,717 3.56% 3.0 ★
14120 North Tonawanda NY $289,695 $1,203 3.24% 3.0 ★

Showing top 50 of 79 ZIP codes. View all →

A great house in the wrong ZIP is still a bad deal — screen every market by cash flow & cap rate.
Open the Market Finder →
Free to search · investor plans from $19/mo

About Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY Real Estate Market

The Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metropolitan statistical area (MSA) encompasses 51 cities and 79 ZIP codes. The average home value across the metro is $303,356, with an average monthly rent of $1,339. Explore individual cities and ZIP codes to find investment opportunities that match your criteria.