C+
Average
67/100

Otsego Elementary School

📚 Pre-K – 05 🏫 Elementary
📍 18505 Tontogany Creek Road, Tontogany, OH 43565
67
Repit Score
out of 100
825
Students
enrolled
20.6:1
Student:Teacher
ratio
$12K
Per Student
spending

What We Evaluated

👨‍🏫 Class Size 20.6:1 student-teacher ratio
💰 Funding $11,724 per student
🏫 School Type Regular

School Information

Address 18505 Tontogany Creek Road
City Tontogany
ZIP Code 43565
District 3905072
NCES School ID 390507204042
Data Year 2024-25

Community Context for 43565

Understanding the community around Otsego Elementary School helps evaluate the school environment and neighborhood.

💰 Income & Economy

Median Household Income $59,000
Per Capita Income $33,115
Poverty Rate 3.1%
Households Earning $100K+ 21.5%

🎓 Education Level

Bachelor's Degree or Higher 6.8%
High School or Higher 97.2%

🏠 Housing

Median Home Value $145,400
Median Rent $1,015
Owner-Occupied 71.5%
Renter-Occupied 28.5%
View full data for ZIP 43565 →

Thinking about moving into this school’s area? See what homes and rents actually cost in ZIP 43565 — values, rent, and how it compares to nearby ZIPs. Free, no signup. See 43565 housing costs →

Student Demographics

Enrollment and demographic breakdown for Otsego Elementary School.

👫 Gender Distribution

Male 49.7%
Female 50.3%

🌎 Race & Ethnicity

White 90.7%
Hispanic/Latino 5.8%
Two or More Races 2.3%
Black 1.0%
Asian 0.1%
American Indian 0.1%

📋 Enrollment Summary

Total Enrollment 825
Teachers (FTE) 40.0
Student:Teacher Ratio 20.6:1

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the Repit School Score for Otsego Elementary School?
Otsego Elementary School has a Repit School Score of 67 out of 100, earning a grade of C+. This score evaluates class size (student-teacher ratio), funding levels, and resources rather than just test scores.
How many students attend Otsego Elementary School?
Otsego Elementary School has 825 students enrolled for the 2024-25 school year. The student-to-teacher ratio is 20.6:1.
What grades does Otsego Elementary School serve?
Otsego Elementary School serves grades Pre-K – 05 and is classified as a Elementary. This is a public school.
How much funding does Otsego Elementary School receive per student?
Otsego Elementary School receives $11,724 in per-pupil spending from its district. This is around the national average.
🏠 Rental Market Around Otsego Elementary School in 43565 ▼
Avg Home Value
$190,988
Avg Monthly Rent
$1,026
1-Year Change
+6.0%
% Renters
28.5%

About Repit School Scores

Traditional school ratings rely heavily on standardized test scores, which often reflect family income more than actual school quality. Repit takes a different approach.

We evaluate schools based on factors that research shows actually impact educational outcomes:

  • Class Size — Smaller classes mean more individual attention and better student outcomes.
  • School Funding — Resources available for programs, teachers, and facilities directly affect education quality.
  • School Environment — School size and structure affect available programs and student experience.

Data source: NCES CCD 2024-25 | Last updated: September 2026